Specifications
| Brand | Fellow |
|---|---|
| Maximum Capacity | 5.5 lb |
| Readability | 0.004 oz |
| Measurement Units Supported | g, oz, lb:oz |
| Tare Function | Yes |
| Display Type | LED |
| Power Source | USB Rechargeable |
| Platform Material | Glass |
| Product Dimensions | 2.6 x 9.1 x 8.5 in |
Pros
- Consistently spot-on
- Quick tare, easy reading
- Solid construction, stable base
Cons
- Limited capacity
- Residue trapping crevices
- Value-for-money doubts
The Verdict
The Fellow Tally Pro kitchen scale hits 8.9/10 for accuracy, with fine 0.004 oz readability and quick tare for smooth baking and portioning. Choose it if you want stable, repeatable weights in bowls, but know the 5.5 lb max can be too low for big batches.
Who it's for: Home bakers and meal preppers who weigh often and care about repeatable grams and ounces. You accept a lower 5.5 lb capacity and a glass surface that needs careful cleanup to avoid residue in small crevices.
Who should skip it: People who regularly weigh large items or big batch cooking. Limited capacity plus value-for-money doubts make it harder to justify when a higher-capacity scale would do the job better.
In-Depth Review
Accuracy
Fellow gives the Tally Pro a precision-first design. The key spec is readability down to 0.004 oz, which maps to 0.1 g increments as reported in third-party testing. That is the kind of step size that lets you split butter portions, tune hydration, and hit small recipe margins without guessing.
Capacity stays realistic for a kitchen scale aimed at baking and prep. The maximum capacity is 5.5 lb, or 2,500 g. Within that usable range, accuracy matters most when you weigh small amounts and then come back for repeat measurements. The scale also has tare listed in the manual, so you can zero the bowl or plate quickly before each pour.
Overall, the accuracy story lines up with the platform design choices. A stable, flat surface under a fine-grain display helps readings stay consistent. This is why the Accuracy pillar scored 8.9, which matches the idea of Precision without drift and Consistently spot-on behavior in real use.
Usability
The usability is the reason this style of scale fits workflows. You get a short-press tare function, and the manual describes it directly as “Short press DIAL to power on and tare.” That means fewer button steps when you move from one bowl to the next.
The display is simple to read for most lighting conditions. It is an LED screen, and it supports multiple units: g, oz, and lb:oz. For recipes that quote ounces but you weigh in grams for accuracy, the lb:oz option also reduces mental math when you are switching between formats.
Fellow also keeps the controls and body compact, with dimensions listed as 2.6 x 9.1 x 8.5 in. That footprint helps when you store it near baking tools. With usability scoring 8.3, the design lands in the “Quick tare, easy reading” zone rather than feeling complicated or fussy.
Build Quality
Build quality comes through in the materials and the way the platform sits. The scale uses glass for both the base and the top. That matters for day-to-day stability. A rigid platform helps prevent tiny shifts when you set down bowls, especially when you weigh thicker ingredients or containers with uneven bottoms.
The build also needs to handle frequent wipe-downs. Glass does not flex, but it changes how cleaning works. In practice, glass surfaces can still collect residue around edges, and the earlier feedback highlights “Residue trapping crevices.” That is a real usability issue, but it also connects to build expectations. Crevices and edges mean more time spent cleaning to keep the platform looking clear and ready.
Even with glass, the scale stays positioned as solid rather than fragile, which matches the Build Quality pillar score of 8.0. The “Solid construction, stable base” idea holds because the scale is designed to feel steady under small-batch weighing, not to wobble or shift during readings.
Features
The Tally Pro’s feature set focuses on practical weighing needs. The biggest usability feature is unit support. The scale lists g, oz, and lb:oz, so you can work in metric, imperial, or mixed units depending on the recipe. That reduces the need to convert before you start weighing.
Power also supports everyday habits. It uses a USB rechargeable system. The documented setup includes USB-C charging via a rechargeable lithium-ion battery, using a USB-C to USB-A cable. That means you are not stuck with disposable batteries for frequent bake sessions.
Readout and measurement detail round out the experience. The display type is LED, and the smallest practical increment is 0.004 oz. With Features scoring 8.8, the model sits at the “Rechargeable convenience plus units” level rather than leaning on add-ons that do not improve results.
Value
Value is where the Tally Pro’s trade-offs show. The most noticeable practical limit is maximum capacity. At 5.5 lb, you can weigh many baking and meal prep loads, but it is not built for larger batch cooking or very heavy cookware. This is also reflected in the pros and cons theme around “Limited capacity.”
There is also a care-and-cleaning reality tied to the glass platform. Residue can collect in small crevices. That impacts workflow more than a typical flat, sealed surface. If you clean quickly between tasks, you may find you need extra attention around the edges.
Still, the underlying measurement spec set supports the value argument. Readability at 0.004 oz and tare functionality helps you get repeatable results without slowing down. Those are the elements that matter most in a scale. With Value scoring 7.5, the experience reads as “Great performance for cost” but with enough constraints that “value” feels conditional, not automatic.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the maximum weight the Fellow Tally Pro can measure?
The Fellow Tally Pro Kitchen Scale holds up to 5.5 lb (about 2.5 kg). If you often weigh large bread batches or big roasting pans, you may hit the limit quickly. For everyday cooking and portioning, this capacity usually covers most needs.
How precise is the display on the Fellow Tally Pro?
It reads to 0.004 oz, which is fine enough for recipes that need accurate small additions. The LED display also makes it easy to see changes as you add ingredients. For repeatable results, the scale also supports fast tare so you can zero containers quickly.
Does it support both grams and ounces, and can it show lb:oz?
Yes. The scale supports g, oz, and lb:oz. That helps if you switch between US recipes and weight-based baking from different sources. You can keep one bowl and change units without converting manually.
How do I power the scale, and how do I recharge it?
The Fellow Tally Pro uses a USB rechargeable power system. You recharge it through a USB connection rather than swapping batteries. If you bake often, keeping it topped up helps you avoid interruptions mid recipe.
What are the dimensions and platform material?
The scale measures 2.6 x 9.1 x 8.5 inches. The platform is glass, which stays smooth for most wipes. The stable base helps when you place a bowl or container for weighing.
Does the Fellow Tally Pro trap residue in crevices, and how do I clean it?
Some residue can collect around small edges and crevices, which means quick wiping may leave bits behind. Use a damp cloth and make sure you reach the areas around the platform edges. For best results, clean right after use so sticky ingredients do not dry on.
Final Verdict
This is a recommended buy for most home cooks who weigh often and want steady results. The Tally Pro delivers consistently spot-on accuracy with quick tare and a clear read. Build feels solid and stable. The main drawback is limited capacity, which can make large batches awkward.
If you mainly portion dry ingredients or small mixes, you will like how it performs. Watch for crevices that trap residue and plan for easy cleaning. If that matches your kitchen, this is a sound pick.
