Skip to content 
Sports & Outdoors
Stay dry in style with the best umbrellas of the year. Whether it’s wind, rain, or sun, these top picks have you covered for any weather. Find your perfect match today!
Finding the perfect eyeliner can be quite the beauty conundrum. With a plethora of options available, from gels to pencils and everything in between, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. But fear not; whether you're looking to master the classic cat-eye or experiment with bold, graphic lines, we're here to guide you through this makeup maze.
In our quest to bring you the best options available, we've dedicated countless hours to scrutinizing the beauty market. By analyzing thousands of customer reviews, comparing features, and assessing the overall performance of various eyeliners, we've curated a list of top picks that promise to deliver on quality and reliability. Our approach ensures that you, the reader, can make informed decisions, whether you prefer the precision of a liquid liner or the versatility of a pencil.
Each eyeliner we recommend has been carefully evaluated not only for its staying power and pigmentation but also for its ease of application, suitability for various skin types, and, of course, its value for money. We understand that makeup is not just about enhancing your look, but also about feeling confident and expressing who you are. That's why our selections focus on products that have consistently satisfied users with different needs and preferences.
Join us as we delve into the wonderful world of eyeliners, ensuring that you make a purchase that truly meets your beauty goals. Your dream eyeliner is just a few scrolls away, backed by thorough research and honest recommendations tailored to elevate your makeup routine.
Overview
Table of Contents
Out Top Picks
Best Overall
Overall Rating | |
Brand | stila |
Finish Type | Glossy |
Dimensions | 4 x 5 x 6 inches |
Weight | 0.32 ounces |
Stila's Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner earns its place in the 'Best Overall' category with its exceptional versatility and user-friendly design. This top-selling eyeliner boasts a streamlined application process, promising seamless, no-skip lines that cater to both intricate and bold eye looks. Its precision allows users to effortlessly create anything from subtle enhancements to daring cat eyes, ensuring it meets all your stylistic needs.
One of the standout features is its quick-drying formula. It sets rapidly, reducing smudging risks and providing a reliable, long-lasting wear. This makes it an ideal choice for those days when you need your makeup to stay put, rain or shine. Its budge-proof qualities are perfect for active lifestyles or humid environments, offering peace of mind that your eyeliner remains intact throughout the day.
While the majority of features impress, some might find its standard pigmentation average. However, the overall performance and adaptability of this eyeliner rightfully secure its high ranking.
Best Smudge Proof
Overall Rating | |
Brand | Urban Decay |
Finish Type | Matte |
Dimensions | 6.02 x 0.55 x 0.55 inches |
Weight | 0.32 ounces |
Urban Decay's 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil truly shines in the Best Smudge Proof category. This eyeliner sets itself apart with an impressive array of 30 richly pigmented shades, offering a delightful spectrum for every style and occasion. The variety of finishes—ranging from matte to metallic—allows for versatile creativity, whether you crave subtle elegance or bold drama.
What really sets this product apart is its creamy, blendable formula. The eyeliner glides seamlessly onto the skin, promising a silky smooth application that welcomes both novices and experts alike. Once it dries, it stays put, boasting waterproof and smudge-proof credentials that maintain an impeccable look throughout the day.
Customers rave about its long-lasting power, although some mention that its rich formula can require precision during application to avoid overuse. However, these minor considerations do little to overshadow its standout features, making it a top choice for those seeking enduring, vibrant eye makeup.
Best Vegan
Overall Rating | |
Brand | ILIA |
Finish Type | Matte |
Dimensions | 3 x 3 x 5 inches |
Weight | 1.28 ounces |
The ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner shines as an exceptional choice for those seeking a vegan eyeliner. This product elegantly marries clean beauty principles with impressive performance. The soft-tip gel formulation ensures an effortlessly smooth application, making it a joy for both makeup novices and experts alike. Thanks to its blendable texture, users can easily create either a sultry, smokey eye or a precise, bold line, all tailored to their personal aesthetic.
Once applied, the gel liner provides robust staying power with its water-resistant qualities, meaning you can face a busy day without worrying about smudging or fading. Its quick-setting attribute further adds to its reliability, letting you maintain a sharp look hour after hour. Thoughtful ingredients highlight ILIA's commitment to clean beauty, with the liner free from carbon black and cyclomethicone, essential for those mindful of their cosmetic choices. While it boasts impressive features, the need for frequent sharpening is one of its few average qualities, but the built-in sharpener ensures easy maintenance.
Best Easy To Use
Overall Rating | |
Brand | NYX PROFESSIONAL |
Finish Type | Matte |
Dimensions | 5.39 x 1.1 x 0.67 inches |
Weight | 0.35 ounces |
The NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner earns its spot as a top contender in the 'Best Easy To Use' category with its standout performance consistently dazzling users. One of its most appealing features is the ultra-precise tip that offers flexibility and ease-of-use, making it a breeze even for beginners to achieve that perfect cat eye. This flexible, precise tip ensures fluid strokes, allowing users to deftly control the thickness of their lines with minimal effort. Whether opting for a fine and natural look or a bold statement, this liner adapts seamlessly to your desired style.
The waterproof formula with a matte black finish delivers long-lasting impact without the worry of smudging, ideal for all-day wear. Although primarily noted for its ease, some users describe its performance as average in terms of drying time. Nonetheless, its cruelty-free certification remains a significant plus, aligning with ethical beauty practices that resonate with many consumers. Overall, the NYX Epic Ink Liner impresses as an accessible and high-quality option.
Best For Sensitive Eyes
Overall Rating | |
Brand | Physicians Formula |
Finish Type | Natural |
Dimensions | 0.94 x 1.88 x 5.63 inches |
Weight | 0.4 ounces |
The Physicians Formula 2-in-1 Eye Booster stands out in the "Best For Sensitive Eyes" category primarily for its dual-functionality and dedication to eye-friendly ingredients. This product excellently combines a liquid eyeliner with an eyelash serum, providing users with both style and care. Crafted with a high-pigment formula, it delivers precision in application, offering a vivid jet black finish that suits both subtle and bold looks. This versatility makes it a great addition to any makeup routine, day or night.
What truly sets this product apart is its lash-boosting complex, which nourishes and conditions lashes while subtly enhancing them. It's particularly beneficial for those with sensitive eyes, as it avoids over 150 known harsh ingredients often found in other products. Moreover, its hypoallergenic nature ensures that it caters specifically to sensitive skin, minimizing the risk of irritation. While some may find its conventional features average, its sensitivity-focused approach and dual benefits make it a remarkable choice.
Best For Smooth Application
Overall Rating | |
Brand | Mabelline |
Finish Type | Satin |
Dimensions | 5.51 x 1.81 x 0.5 inches |
Weight | 0.32 ounces |
The Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner stands out in the 'Best For Smooth Application' category due to its remarkable performance and user-friendly design. One of the most praised features is its flex-tip brush that adapts seamlessly to the shape of your eye, ensuring a glide without the usual skips or gaps associated with liquid liners. This innovative brush, combined with the hexagonal grip, allows for exceptional control, making it accessible for both beginners and seasoned makeup enthusiasts.
What truly enhances its appeal is the lasting power of this eyeliner. It maintains a vibrant, smudge-free intensity for up to 24 hours, which is a significant advantage for those long days or nights out.
While its performance is generally stellar, some users have noted that mastering the perfect thickness might require a bit of practice. However, this doesn't overshadow its standout qualities, making it an excellent choice for anyone seeking a smooth and hassle-free application.
What To Look For
Selecting the right eyeliner can enhance your makeup routine and accentuate your eyes beautifully. Consider these essential features to find the best option for your needs.
- Type: Eyeliners come in various forms such as pencil, liquid, gel, and felt-tip; each type offers a different application style and finish.
- Color Pigmentation: High pigmentation ensures that the color appears vivid and bold on your skin, providing a striking look with minimal application.
- Longevity: A long-lasting formula is crucial for maintaining your look throughout the day without the need for frequent touch-ups.
- Ease of Application: Consider an eyeliner that glides smoothly and is easy to control, facilitating a precise application regardless of experience level.
- Waterproof Properties: Waterproof eyeliners resist smudging and running, ensuring your makeup stays intact through sweat, tears, or damp conditions.
- Hypoallergenic: Formulas that are hypoallergenic or tested for sensitive skin minimize irritation, especially for those with sensitive or allergy-prone eyes.
By focusing on these features, you can find an eyeliner that complements your eyes and fits seamlessly into your beauty regimen.
How We Select Our Products
Selecting the top eyeliners featured in this blog post is a meticulous process, designed to ensure that our readers receive only the most reliable and well-researched recommendations. Our dedication begins with an extensive analysis of customer ratings and reviews from various trusted online platforms. By summarizing real user experiences, we gain insights into the performance and satisfaction levels associated with each product.The next step involves a comprehensive feature comparison. We examine each eyeliner's specific attributes, such as formulation, pigment intensity, water-resistance, and ease of application. This detailed evaluation helps us identify which products stand out in terms of innovation and usability, catering to diverse consumer preferences, whether someone is looking for a bold cat-eye or subtle definition.
Value for money is another crucial factor in our selection criteria. While high-end products often promise top-notch results, we also focus on more affordable options that deliver outstanding performance without breaking the bank. By balancing quality and cost, we ensure that our recommendations cater to a wide audience with varying budgets.
Throughout the selection process, we consider additional factors such as brand reputation, availability, and packaging. This holistic approach allows us to present a well-rounded perspective on each product, ensuring our readers have all the information needed to make an informed purchasing decision.
Our dedication to providing accurate and useful content means that the eyeliners listed in this blog have been meticulously researched and handpicked. Each recommendation echoes our commitment to quality, reliability, and consumer satisfaction, making your choice as effortless and enjoyable as possible.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right eyeliner can transform your makeup routine by addressing specific needs and enhancing your natural features. The key benefits of selecting the ideal eyeliner are numerous and make a significant impact on your overall look.Firstly, the right eyeliner can greatly enhance eye shape and color. Whether you have round, almond, or hooded eyes, selecting an eyeliner that complements your eye shape can help achieve your desired look, from dramatic cat eyes to subtle, natural enhancement. Moreover, matching the eyeliner color with your eye color can make your eyes pop, adding depth and allure to your gaze.
Another benefit is the variety of formulations available to address different wear conditions and personal preferences. For those with sensitive eyes or who wear contact lenses, hypoallergenic or ophthalmologist-tested eyeliners minimize irritation, ensuring a comfortable experience. Additionally, waterproof formulas are ideal for long-lasting wear, resisting smudges and running in humid conditions or if you have oily skin.
The choice of eyeliner can also vary based on application ease and the precision required. Pencil eyeliners offer versatility and are great for beginners due to their ease of use and ability to create both crisp lines and softer, smudged looks. Liquid and gel eyeliners, on the other hand, are perfect for those who enjoy experimenting with sharp, defined lines or bold artistic designs.
Ultimately, choosing the right eyeliner empowers you to express your creativity while meeting the unique needs of your eyes. By considering factors such as eye shape, sensitivity, preferred look, and wear duration, you can make an informed decision that enhances your beauty routine and leaves you feeling confident and polished.
